.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Tone Clusters: the Joyce Carol Oates discussion group archive

Friday, October 21, 2005

RE: JCO: RE: Talent vs Experience

hi steve!
So, are you saying that JCO keeps relying on talent instead of experience? Although I believe most of the stories reflect the crude reality she hasn't had the time to live.
 
Joy

jandsmerritt <jandsmerritt@earthlink.net> wrote:
Hi Everyone:
 
I notice that because of Mailer's unfortunate phrasing, we haven't addressed the underlying question of how far talent (in any artist at all) can go to make up for lack of experience.
 
JCO of course has managed to write about an enormous variety of people in an enormous variety of situations.  She does her homework (though I noticed, when reading "Blonde", the one book I've read by her where I'm familiar with any of the settings, that she did get occasionally get a few details wrong, but still she did well for someone who's never lived in L.A.), and that's a big help, but I think she also proves that empathy and imagination in general can take you a long way.  On the other hand, she certainly goes back to upstate New York and to the 1950s a lot.
 
Steve
 


Find your next car at Yahoo! Canada Autos